Analysis summary
Why are US states restricting public adjusters? Carriers and insurance industry lobbyists are pushing back on a fast-growing profession, sources tell Insurance Insider US, with at least a dozen states having recently passed or considering new restrictions, including Texas, New York and New Jersey, and Kentucky passing a two-year prohibition on issuing new public adjuster licences. This analysis shows how carriers are adding policy language that stops policyholders hiring public adjusters, now the subject of lawsuits in Massachusetts and Florida, and why adjusters concede that bad actors have fuelled the backlash. It delivers fast insight on the profession's growth, with Texas going from 77 public adjusters to around 2,000 in 20 years, on a proposed code of professional conduct, and on New York adjusters' push for a bad faith law.Subscribe to get comprehensive access to our exclusive analysis in the full platform.
The public adjusting industry has been expanding at a high clip in recent years, but a groundswell of opposition from carriers and state legislatures threatens to stunt further proliferation, sources told Insurance Insider US.
Several trends are driving sector growth, including elevated cat risks in this climate change era where policyholder claims increasingly wind up in dispute, sources continued. Meanwhile, low barriers to entry in many states have allowed for a flood of new adjusting firms to swoop in, augmenting insureds' ability to advocate for payouts.
That hasn’t sat well with carriers, who have been inserting new anti-public adjuster language into their terms and conditions. At the same time, insurance industry lobbyists have been making inroads compelling state lawmakers to drive opposition through new legislation.
Tensions promise to heat up over the next year as politicians jump into the fray and demand for adjusters ticks up from a variety of insureds – from homeowners and other personal lines customers to commercial lines and small to middle market businesses.
The fight also plays out in the day-to-day wrangling of claims, according to Jonathan Wilkofsky, executive director of the New York Public Adjuster Association (NYPAA) and a partner at Wilkofsky, Friedman, Karel & Cummins.
At an NYPAA conference last week, Wilkofsky accused carriers of dragging their feet on claims.
“The current moment is the worst that's ever been. Not just in terms of the profession being under attack, but also in the inability to get claims paid timely. I think they're connected,” Wilkofsky told Insurance Insider US from the conference sidelines.
Carriers have been making it harder for insureds to get their claims assessed by adding contract language prohibiting policyholders from hiring public adjusters – something that's the subject of ongoing litigation, Merlin Law Group founder and president Chip Merlin said on a panel.
"We're starting to see forms that are being filed all over the country to prevent policyholders from hiring public adjusters," said Merlin, who specializes in litigating insurance coverage and property damage claims. "There are lawsuits being filed about that, both in Massachusetts and in Florida, regarding the enforcement of this."
Massachusetts banned this practice earlier this year in a law that goes into effect next month.
The Florida Association of Public Insurance Adjusters and the National Association of Public Insurance Adjusters (NAPIA) filed a lawsuit in Florida last year challenging anti-public adjuster endorsements.
A growing number of state legislative actions are also adding pressure to the profession, and at least a dozen states have recently passed or are considering passing new restrictions on public adjusters, including Texas, New York and New Jersey, noted Eastern Public CEO and NAPIA vice president Brian Evans.
One of the more aggressive legislative moves came this past April in Kentucky, where the state passed a two-year prohibition on the issuance of public adjuster licenses, among other restrictions.
“Kentucky came out of nowhere,” Evans said, adding that he has heard Tennessee may be mulling PA restrictions of its own, among other states.
The insurance industry’s opposition to public adjuster growth isn’t entirely rooted in naturally competing agendas. Public adjusters concede that their industry has been beset by unqualified bad actors from within – including swarms of fly-by-night newcomers who have taken advantage of slim regulatory oversight and rising demand to bilk policyholders.
"They're the ones who the departments of insurance, who the news media, especially insurance propagandists, are out trying to show, 'Well, this is the typical public adjuster. We've got to do something about it,'" Merlin said. "So pretenders are really dangerous."
Unscrupulous practices include signing clients only to hand the job off to an attorney for a fee, conspiring with contractors to overbill for work, and even talking clients into making fraudulent claims with their insurer that the adjuster knows aren't covered by their policy, sources noted.
A rise in private equity rollups of mom-and-pop public adjuster shops around the country has also been ruffling feathers in the insurance world.
To defend against this, Merlin said the industry needs to raise its standards, and work is already underway.
Last month, a coalition of 16 public adjusters, insurance attorneys and other industry professionals proposed the creation of a formal public adjusting code of professional conduct. The proposed code aims to quash bad behavior in the adjusting space – before courts or regulators step in to mandate fixes.
“It's a noble profession, when it's done well,” Wilkofsky said. “If you don't have the training and the moral compass, don't be in business.”
Data on the growth in public adjusting is spotty and varies widely state-by-state, when it can be found at all, but sources say the industry has been booming in recent years. Anecdotal data seems to support it.
In the past 20 years, the number of public adjusters in Texas alone jumped to around 2,000 from just 77, according to Steven Badger, a partner at Zelle LLP who works mostly with insurance companies. Texas also prohibits insurers from blocking policyholders from hiring public adjusters.
Badger said the low barriers to entry are fueling the growth, and while he doesn't believe public adjusting should be banned altogether, he does see the need for the industry to raise its standards.
"I support the role of the well trained and professional public adjuster in the claims process," Badger said. "They do play a role. The problem we have is … lots of people are jumping into the profession who are not professionals."
While the better actors in the public adjuster space aim to establish industry best practices through self-policing, they’ve also pressed forward with their own lobbying efforts and litigations against insurers around contract terms they assert are unfair to consumers.
In New York, NYPAA continues to lobby for its proposed bad faith bill, which will strengthen policyholders’ ability to sue carriers that are acting in bad faith.
"We have no bad faith law, and we have no regulator watching the henhouse in any appropriate manner," Wilkofsky said.
Got a tip for us? Reach out confidentially here.
Several trends are driving sector growth, including elevated cat risks in this climate change era where policyholder claims increasingly wind up in dispute, sources continued. Meanwhile, low barriers to entry in many states have allowed for a flood of new adjusting firms to swoop in, augmenting insureds' ability to advocate for payouts.
How are carriers restricting public adjusters?Carriers have been making it harder for insureds to get their claims assessed by adding contract language prohibiting policyholders from hiring public adjusters – something that's the subject of ongoing litigation, Merlin Law Group founder and president Chip Merlin said on a panel.
Which states are restricting public adjusters?At least a dozen states have recently passed or are considering passing new restrictions on public adjusters, including Texas, New York and New Jersey, noted Eastern Public CEO and NAPIA vice president Brian Evans.
How many public adjusters are there in Texas?In the past 20 years, the number of public adjusters in Texas alone jumped to around 2,000 from just 77, according to Steven Badger, a partner at Zelle LLP who works mostly with insurance companies.
Why do insurers oppose the growth of public adjusters?The insurance industry’s opposition to public adjuster growth isn’t entirely rooted in naturally competing agendas. Public adjusters concede that their industry has been beset by unqualified bad actors from within – including swarms of fly-by-night newcomers who have taken advantage of slim regulatory oversight and rising demand to bilk policyholders.
What unscrupulous practices are public adjusters accused of?Unscrupulous practices include signing clients only to hand the job off to an attorney for a fee, conspiring with contractors to overbill for work, and even talking clients into making fraudulent claims with their insurer that the adjuster knows aren't covered by their policy, sources noted.
What is the proposed public adjusting code of conduct?A coalition of 16 public adjusters, insurance attorneys and other industry professionals proposed the creation of a formal public adjusting code of professional conduct. The proposed code aims to quash bad behavior in the adjusting space – before courts or regulators step in to mandate fixes.
By Caleb Harshberger
15 October, 2026
Request your free trial today to unlock our complete intelligence platform.