Analysis summary
Are companies still using captive insurance? Fewer are, according to Ferma and PwC's Global Risk Manager Survey: 27% of risk and insurance managers said they had used a captive or similar vehicle in the past 12 months, down from 37% in 2024, as commercial insurance conditions have softened. This analysis of the survey's responses from more than 1,300 risk and insurance managers shows that the share considering a captive was largely stable, at 9% against 10%, and that risk retention fell to 56% from 62% in 2024 and 73% in 2022. It delivers fast insight on why brokers distinguish strategic captive users from opportunistic ones, and why Aon's Tracey-Lee Kus sees much more interest in captives despite the softer market.Subscribe to get comprehensive access to our exclusive analysis in the full platform.
The share of risk and insurance managers who said they have used a captive over the past 12 months dropped by 10 points between 2024 and 2026, according to Ferma and PwC’s Global Risk Manager Survey Report released this week.
A smaller proportion of respondents – at 27% – said they had used a captive or similar vehicle to transfer risk over the past 12 months, compared with 37% per the last edition of this survey, which came out in 2024.
Even so, the share of respondents who said they considered using a captive over past 12 months was largely stable at 9% in 2026, compared with 10% in 2024.
About 31% of respondents also said they would use an existing captive over the next two years, down by 4 points relative to 2024, and 14% said they’d create a new insurance or reinsurance captive, down by 3 points relative to 2024.
The report suggested that, “while captives remain strategically important, organisations may be prioritising the optimisation of existing vehicles over the establishment of new structures”.
The survey collected responses from more than 1,300 risk and insurance managers, most of which (78%) were European.
Earlier this year, sister publication Insurance Insider US reported that the rapid growth of captives in the US – spurred by the property hard market and challenges in general liability – was here to stay, even amid a softening market.
In terms of the UK, this publication reported in the summer that the captive framework could strengthen London's risk-hub status as faster approvals and lighter supervision aim to boost domicile appeal.
The decline in captive use comes alongside a broader reduction in risk retention as commercial insurance conditions have softened.
Risk retention remained the most popular financing strategy in the Ferma survey at 56%, but that was down from 62% in 2024 and 73% in 2022.
However, discussions with brokers and carriers at Ferma Forum in Rotterdam this week suggested the fall in captive use should not necessarily be read as companies losing interest in the vehicles.
One broker distinguished between companies that use captives strategically because they consider themselves the natural holder of certain risks, and those that use them opportunistically when commercial insurance becomes expensive.
The latter group is more likely to move risk back into the traditional market when capacity increases and pricing falls, while strategic users are less influenced by the insurance cycle.
Aon co-CEO of EMEA Tracey-Lee Kus told Insurance Insider interest in captives remained evident despite softer commercial conditions, with buyers increasingly considering how they could use the vehicles to retain or incubate exposures and exercise greater control over their risks.
“We’re suddenly seeing much more interest in captives, and normally captives are hard market,” Kus said.
“People want to have a better control of their risks and think about it differently.”
Rather than signalling a wholesale retreat from captives, the figures could, therefore, be consistent with some tactical-use unwinding in the softer market while longer-term strategic interest remains.
Got a tip for us? Reach out confidentially here.
A smaller proportion of respondents – at 27% – said they had used a captive or similar vehicle to transfer risk over the past 12 months, compared with 37% per the last edition of this survey, which came out in 2024.
Are companies planning to use captives in future?About 31% of respondents also said they would use an existing captive over the next two years, down by 4 points relative to 2024, and 14% said they’d create a new insurance or reinsurance captive, down by 3 points relative to 2024.
Why has captive use fallen?The decline in captive use comes alongside a broader reduction in risk retention as commercial insurance conditions have softened.
Is risk retention still the most popular risk financing strategy?Risk retention remained the most popular financing strategy in the Ferma survey at 56%, but that was down from 62% in 2024 and 73% in 2022.
What is the difference between strategic and opportunistic captive users?One broker distinguished between companies that use captives strategically because they consider themselves the natural holder of certain risks, and those that use them opportunistically when commercial insurance becomes expensive. The latter group is more likely to move risk back into the traditional market when capacity increases and pricing falls, while strategic users are less influenced by the insurance cycle.
Is interest in captives still growing?Aon co-CEO of EMEA Tracey-Lee Kus told Insurance Insider interest in captives remained evident despite softer commercial conditions, with buyers increasingly considering how they could use the vehicles to retain or incubate exposures and exercise greater control over their risks.
Who took part in the Ferma and PwC Global Risk Manager Survey?The survey collected responses from more than 1,300 risk and insurance managers, most of which (78%) were European.
By Mehr Gill and Stephanie Denton
9 October, 2026
Request your free trial today to unlock our complete intelligence platform.